Editorial Policy and Corrections
This page sets out the rules the editorial desk follows when it writes, reviews and corrects a guide. It applies to every page on the site, including the tools.
Independence
Edge & Pivot sells nothing and takes no payment for coverage. There are no affiliate links. A brand or retailer cannot buy a mention, a ranking or a place in a guide. Makers and sellers are named only inside the source citations, where a reader can check what a manufacturer actually published. A name does not appear in a title, a heading or the body text as a recommendation.
Sources
Guides cite the pages they rely on. The sources we accept are:
- manufacturer care, sharpening and size-chart pages, and the manuals a maker publishes on its own website;
- university extension services, for garden tools and sewing or textile subjects;
- government and safety bodies, such as the US Consumer Product Safety Commission and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, for safety wording;
- government pages from licensing boards, where the subject is disinfection or hygiene wording;
- a standard dictionary, for the meaning of a term.
We do not cite forums, comment threads, other blogs, or unnamed experts. Where a fact is only available in a paywalled standard, we name the standard and cite only what its free official page says.
Each citation is to the exact page the desk read. If a claim cannot be traced to a page we have opened, we remove the claim rather than soften it.
Numbers, sizes and prices
- Every number in a guide, such as a grinding angle, a size or a measurement, must come from an opened source. Where no source states a value, the guide says it is a planning assumption and tells the reader to check the maker’s guide.
- We do not publish prices, or price ranges, unless the figure comes from a dated primary source. Where a price is shown, the date of the source is shown with it.
- Cost pages, where they exist, explain the factors that move a cost rather than inventing a total.
Rankings and recommendations
We do not publish “best” lists, rankings or a single pick for every user. Our guides set out the types, the typical uses and the trade-offs, and say which questions help a reader decide. A tool’s result is a suggestion based on the answers given, not a verdict on any product.
Desk review
Each guide is reviewed by the editorial desk against the sources it cites before publication. This is a review of the sources. It is not a laboratory test, a product trial, or an assessment by a licensed professional, and the site does not claim otherwise. Pages are dated, and the “updated” date changes when the content changes in a way a reader would notice.
Safety wording
Scissors and shears are sharp tools. Where a guide describes sharpening, cleaning or handling, it includes a short safety note and follows the maker’s instructions. For matters that need a trained person, such as a blade that has been damaged, we say so.
Corrections
If a guide is wrong, we want to know. Send the page address and the source that shows the correct position to the address on the contact page.
- Factual errors are corrected, and where the change matters to the reader, a dated note explains what changed.
- A source that no longer loads is replaced with a working source, or the claim is removed.
- We do not quietly rewrite a claim to avoid a correction request.
Who to ask
Questions about this policy can go through the same contact page. For background on the site, see about Edge & Pivot.